This blog was found on CrossFit Surf City in Huntington Beach.
The next time somebody tries to tell you that their P90X DVD is harder than CrossFit refer them to this article. This is courtesy of Full Potential Fitness and sums up some of the flaws in the P90X program.
"P90X. It seems only fitting that I write my opinions on this program since everyone seems to be asking me. It has taken me a while to formulate my thoughts but keep in mind that I have yet to devote 90 days to this program and nor do I intend to.
From the looks of the website as well as the infomercials the whole concept of P90X is that they utilize the “revolutionary” and “advanced training technique” called Muscle Confusion. Basically, you never give your body the same workout so that your muscles are constantly “guessing” and having to adapt. Since the adaptation process of training is what creates the spike in metabolism it would seem like this program would work right? Correct. I have seen people do P90X with decent results and I’ve seen people do P90X with poor result. The difference? THE DIET. Those who followed a clean diet found better results. What does this mean? It means what every strength and conditioning coach will tell you, “You can’t train a crappy diet.” I don’t care how many air squats you do in 20 minutes time, if you are eating fried chicken on the daily you will remain fat….or get fatter for that matter.
I will say that I have a few gripes with P90X though. Here they are…
1. “Muscle Confusion” IS NOT A NEW CONCEPT. It is one of the AGE-OLD principles of a proper training program. I don’t care if you’re a strength athlete, a sports athlete, or just a gym rat…giving your body new stimuli to adapt to goes back to the CORE BASICS of training. It’s not revolutionary or cutting-edge (although I understand that P90X is just trying to make a buck so they market it as something new that they supposedly came up with). The principle is actually called the GAS principle. General Adaptation Syndrome. Look it up. It’s been around. Oh yeah, and it’s pretty much the model that CrossFit follows. Just look at my WODs for the proof.
2. Programming – P90X claims that it’s about all around fitness. It says that it’s about transforming your whole body, yet many of the DVD’s are centered around body-part splits….and ooollllldddd-school body part splits at that. I mean, who in their right mind still spends an hour doing a “Chest, Shoulders, and Triceps” workout? I mean c’mon, I think drinking a shot of Tabasco sauce would be more exciting. I do understand and appreciate them factoring workouts like Yoga X and X Stretch either as a means of recovery workout or as a way to instill flexibility and quality tissue, but I wish they would encourage this as a piece to each workout and not make it a complete workout all on its own.
3. Intensity – Following this program greatly lacks in accountability on a number of levels. First, you’re allowed to pause the dvd. Now, I know all people start at different levels of fitness and so some people need more rest than others, but I guarantee you that most people are still going to get too much rest. Rather than encouraging “rest as needed” principles, I’d rather scale down the workout to allow people to maintain the same high-intensity total output I’m looking for. Second, this DVD doesn’t know if you’re even doing your exercises properly! I understand that not everyone can afford a trainer or a coach, but if you aren’t going to do your bodyweight squats below parallel with a strongly arched lower back like you’re supposed to, you’re not doing enough work. I don’t care if this means you can get more reps in less time. Third, there’s no progression in strength. I know P90X claims to get your stronger, and I don’t argue that it does (I know people who can do pullups now because of P90X…but I know people who can do more than them because of Crossfit. Go figure). Unless you’re willing to constantly buy more dumbbells, you’re not going to get stronger. Strength improvements can be seen in at least 6 weeks. That’s 42 days. Last time I checked the DVD was called P90X, not P42. That means after your strength has gone up if you aren’t constantly pushing heavier loads, you’re just getting weaker. Also, if you can’t get your hands on a barbell to do some deadlifts and a bar on your back for some heavy squats, you’re not getting stronger. And ladies, I know you’re going to say, “I don’t want to get bulky.” Unless you are an Eastern European powerlifter on the juice, that won’t happen so quit worrying.
To its credit though P90X DOES get people exercising and it’s a lot better than someone taking the pages out of a bodybuilding magazine and mindlessly busting out bicep curls and lateral raises.
